MCP vs CLI for AI Agents: A Comparative Analysis of Tool Integration Strategies for Autonomous Systems
Paper · https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.30157
arXiv:2610.30157v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: AI agents require interfaces to interact with external systems such as files, APIs, databases, and cloud services. Two competing paradigms have emerged: CLI (Command Line Interface), where agents execute shell commands directly, and MCP (Model Context Protocol), a structured JSON-RPC protocol providing governed, typed tool access. This paper presents a comparative analysis across 14 evaluation dimensions, supported by worked examples, security assessment against established compliance frameworks, and economic modeling. Our analysis indicates that CLI provides superior efficiency for single-user, local-only workflows, while MCP addresses requirements that CLI fundamentally cannot satisfy, including fine-grained access control, credential isolation, structured audit, and multi-tenant governance. We further examine how progressive disclosure techniques eliminate MCP's historical weakness (context window overhead), yielding token efficiency comparable to CLI while preserving its architectural benefits. A hybrid architecture is recommended for production systems. This analysis draws upon academic, government, and industry sources including NSA formal guidance (CSI U/OO/6030316-26), OWASP security standards, and economic modeling from BCG and Gartner.
First seen by Oriel on .
AI summary
The paper compares CLI and MCP for AI-agent tool integration, arguing that CLI suits local single-user workflows while MCP supports governance needs and production systems benefit from a hybrid architecture.
- The analysis evaluates the two approaches across 14 dimensions, including security, compliance, and economic considerations.
- CLI is presented as more efficient for single-user, local-only workflows.
- MCP provides fine-grained access control, credential isolation, structured audit, and multi-tenant governance that CLI cannot satisfy.
- Progressive disclosure can reduce MCP context-window overhead to token efficiency comparable to CLI while retaining its architectural benefits.
#ai agents #mcp #cli #tool integration
Generated by gpt-5.6-sol. Check the original for details.
Aliases
| Source | External ID | URL |
|---|---|---|
| arXiv AI Papers | oai:arXiv.org:2610.30157v1 | https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.30157 Read discussion |