We need more goat sacrifices
Web page · https://experimental-history.com/p/we-need-more-goat-sacrifices
First seen by Oriel on .
AI summary
The essay argues that social policies and philanthropic programs need ritualized humility because many well-intentioned interventions fail, produce null effects, or are never properly evaluated.
- Examples include ineffective school grants, diversity officers, Afghan employment programs, laptops, vaccination messages, Medicaid work requirements, and abstinence-only sex education.
- Peter Rossi’s satirical laws propose that large social programs usually have zero net impact, better evaluations find more null effects, and ambitious programs are likelier to fail.
- The misinterpreted “illusion of control” study illustrates how people confuse intention with causation, encouraging interventions without checking whether they achieve their goals.
- NSF-funded STEM projects were not experimentally evaluated 76% of the time, while many federal programs lack defined goals or data measuring progress.
- NYU’s $100 million free-tuition program increased applications 47% but did not change students’ economic backgrounds or specialty choices.
#social policy #program evaluation #behavioral science #philanthropy
Generated by gpt-5.6-sol. Check the original for details.
Metric trends
Last 30 days · Up to 120 recorded samples per source and metric, with reposts kept separate · First and latest retained
Points
Score reported by the source.
- Hacker News: 221, latest observation ; +217 over observed period since
Comments
Comment count reported by the source.
- Hacker News: 135, latest observation ; +135 over observed period since
Aliases
| Source | External ID | URL |
|---|---|---|
| Hacker News | 50444308 | https://www.experimental-history.com/p/we-need-more-goat-sacrifices Read discussion |
| Hacker News | 50452652 | https://www.experimental-history.com/p/we-need-more-goat-sacrifices Read discussion |